Top 10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Tennessee Medical License Defense Lawyer

Tennessee health professionals facing a board complaint or investigation know how much is at stake: your career, reputation, and ability to practice. Before you trust anyone with that, it helps to ask the right questions. While laws and processes can change, below are ten smart questions to ask before you hire a medical license defense lawyer in Tennessee, plus why the answers matter.

Because this is general information, it is not legal advice for your specific situation.

1. Do you regularly handle Tennessee medical and professional license cases?

License defense is its own world. You want someone who regularly handles:

• Cases before the Tennessee Department of Health and the relevant board (Medical Examiners, Nursing, Pharmacy, etc.)
• Investigations, informal conferences, and full administrative hearings, not just criminal or civil court cases

Ask for concrete examples: recent board matters, the types of professionals they represent, and how often they appear in these forums. A lawyer who knows the Tennessee boards’ procedures and personalities can often spot issues and opportunities early that others miss.

2. Have you represented professionals in my field?

A physician’s case looks different from a nurse’s, pharmacist’s, or therapist’s case. Standards of care, common pitfalls, and board expectations vary by license.

Good follow‑ups:

• How many nurses / physicians / advanced practice providers / pharmacists have you represented?
• Have you handled cases involving my specific issue (charting, prescribing, documentation, boundary concerns, substance use, etc.)?

An attorney with experience in your specific profession can better anticipate how your board views certain conduct and what mitigation will resonate.

3. What is your experience with Tennessee board investigations (not just hearings)?

Many cases are won or lost long before a formal hearing is scheduled. The early investigative stage is critical: how you respond to that first letter or phone call can shape everything that comes after.

Ask:

• How do you typically handle the initial board letter or investigator contact?
• Do you help draft responses and control communication with the investigator?
• How often have you seen cases closed at the investigation stage?

You want a lawyer who focuses on early damage control and knows when a detailed explanation helps—and when silence or a limited response is safer.

4. What is your approach to written responses and interviews with investigators?

Some lawyers tell clients to “just cooperate” and talk. Others never want the client to speak. The best answer is usually in between.

Questions to ask:

• Will you help draft my written response to the board?
• Under what circumstances would you agree to an in‑person or phone interview with an investigator?
• How do you prepare clients for those conversations?

Look for someone who will carefully shape your story, protect against unintentional admissions, and insist on proper boundaries with investigators.

5. How does your nursing background (or healthcare experience) help in these cases?

If the firm has an attorney who worked as a nurse before becoming a lawyer, that is a real advantage. A lawyer with bedside experience understands:

• Short staffing, heavy workloads, and real‑world pressures that lead to alleged “negligence” or documentation problems
• How policies, charting shortcuts, and hospital culture actually work in practice
• The language and clinical context behind orders, assessments, and medication decisions

Ask specifically:

• How do you use your nursing experience when evaluating charts, policies, and alleged errors?
• Have you used that background successfully to explain a client’s actions to a board consultant or panel?

You want someone who can translate your day‑to‑day reality into terms regulators can understand and respect.

6. What outcomes have you achieved in cases like mine?

Ethical attorneys will not promise results but they can describe past outcomes and the range of possibilities:

• Complaints closed with no action
• Non‑disciplinary letters or advisory letters
• Conditional or probationary orders
• Suspensions, reinstatements, or practice limitations

Ask:

• In cases like mine (e.g., documentation, prescribing, boundary allegations), what outcomes have you seen?
• How do you decide when to push for dismissal, when to negotiate a consent order, and when to go to a hearing?

This helps you understand both the lawyer’s experience and their philosophy: cautious and settlement‑oriented, aggressive and hearing‑oriented, or balanced.

7. How do you handle collateral consequences (NPDB, employment, credentialing)?

Board action is only part of the story. You also have to think about:

• National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) reports
• Hospital and facility privileges
• Credentialing with insurers
• Multi‑state licensure and future job prospects

Ask:

• Do you advise on how potential outcomes will affect my job, privileges, and future licensing?
• Will you help me respond to employer, hospital, or credentialing questions about the case?
• Do you consider NPDB and other reporting issues when negotiating settlements?

A good license defense lawyer is thinking beyond “Can we close this case?” and looking at “What will this look like on your record five years from now?”

8. What is your strategy for settlement vs. hearing?

Many Tennessee board cases resolve through consent orders or informal processes; relatively few go all the way to a contested hearing. Your lawyer should have a clear idea of how to navigate that spectrum.

Ask:

• How do you decide whether to accept a proposed consent order or take the case to a hearing?
• Will you walk me through the pros and cons of each option, including long‑term record and reporting issues?
• How involved will I be in that decision?

You want someone who will not pressure you into a quick deal just to close the file—but also will not push you into a risky hearing without a clear plan and frank risk‑benefit discussion.

9. How will we communicate and who will be working on my case?

License matters are stressful and often slow. Clear communication can reduce anxiety and help you make good decisions.

Clarify:

• How often will I get updates, and by what method (phone, email, portal)?
• Will I primarily work with the attorney I’m meeting or with staff?
• How quickly do you usually respond to client questions?

Especially for healthcare professionals used to fast‑paced environments, knowing when to expect answers can make the process more manageable.

10. How do you structure fees for medical license defense?

Cost matters, and you deserve transparency up front. Medical license defense can involve:

• Flat fees for certain stages (e.g., initial response, informal conference)
• Hourly billing for investigation, negotiation, and hearing preparation
• Additional costs for experts, record review, or transcripts

Ask:

• Do you offer an initial consultation, and what does it cover?
• Do you charge flat fees, hourly fees, or a mix, and what’s included?
• What other costs should I expect (experts, copying records, travel, etc.)?

A good lawyer will be straightforward about fees and help you prioritize the work that makes the most difference for your case and your budget.

‍

If your Tennessee medical license—or any healthcare license—is under investigation or you’ve received a board complaint, do not wait to get help. The sooner an experienced lawyer steps in, the more options you may have to protect your license, your career, and your reputation.

Contact Hagar & Phillips today to schedule a confidential consultation and get clear, practical guidance tailored to your situation. Call our office at 615-784-4588 and let our team, including an attorney with real nursing experience, help you navigate the board process and fight for your future.

‍