What is Physical Control in a DUI Case
September 15, 2023
Home » Insights »

What is Physical Control in a DUI Case?

Physical control in a DUI case means that the defendant has the likely means to operate the vehicle even if he or she was not actually driving the vehicle at the time that they were stopped by the police. The concept is a vitally important one, because Tennessee’s DUI law prohibits not just driving a vehicle but also being in “physical control” of a vehicle while intoxicated.

The Tennessee Supreme Court explained in State v. Lawrence, 849 S.W.2d 741 (Tenn. 1993) that to determine whether a DUI defendant was in physical control of the vehicle, the courts look to the totality of the circumstances.  The state supreme court also identified the following five factors to consider: 

The location of the defendant in relation to the vehicle;

The location of the ignition key;

Whether the vehicle’s motor was running;

The defendant’s ability, but for intoxication, to direct the use or non-use of the vehicle; and

The extent to which the vehicle is capable of being operated or moved under its own power. 

All of these factors can be important to determine physical control. For example, a defendant found inside a vehicle intoxicated with the keys in the ignition is likely to be considered in “physical control” of the vehicle.  However, if the defendant is in the backseat of the vehicle, the motor is not running, and the keys are not on the defendant’s person or in the ignition, there is a good argument that the defendant is not in physical control of the vehicle. A person standing outside a running vehicle may well be in physical control of the vehicle absent other circumstance.

Because of the flexibility inherent in such a multi-factor test, you need an experienced criminal defense attorney to be able to argue on your behalf and protect your rights. Eric L. Phillips of the law firm Hagar & Phillips has handled many DUI cases and has the experience and skill necessary to handle your case. 

The information provided on this blog is meant for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical or legal advice. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind regarding the completeness, accuracy, reliability, or suitability of the blog content. Any reliance on this information is at your own risk. This blog may discuss legal topics, but for advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified attorney. We do not assume responsibility for actions taken based on the information herein. We are not liable for any losses or damages resulting from the use of this blog. Links to other websites are not endorsements, and technical issues may affect blog availability. By using this blog, you agree to this disclaimer. Hagar Phillips Attorneys At Law
Recent Articles |  View All
Can a Misdemeanor Charge Result in License Suspension in Tennessee?
Many licensed professionals in Tennessee assume that only felony convictions can threaten their careers. However, even a misdemeanor charge—from a DUI to a minor theft or assault—can trigger investigations and potential license suspension. Understanding how misdemeanors affect professional licensure, what steps you should take, and how to protect your career is essential for anyone facing criminal charges.
Read Post
Understanding the Timeline: From Criminal Charge to License Discipline in Tennessee
Being accused of a crime in Tennessee can have far-reaching consequences, especially if you hold a professional license. Whether you’re a nurse, teacher, lawyer, real estate agent, or other licensed professional, a criminal charge can trigger a licensing board investigation that may affect your career. Understanding the timeline and process from criminal charge to potential disciplinary action is critical to protecting your professional future.
Read Post
How a DUI Conviction Affects Your Insurance and Financial Future in Tennessee
Facing a DUI conviction in Tennessee is stressful, and many drivers don’t realize just how far-reaching the consequences can be. Beyond legal penalties such as fines, jail time, and license suspension, a DUI can have a serious and lasting impact on your insurance rates, financial stability, and long-term expenses.
Read Post